New provinces: now or never
The debate over the creation of new provinces or administrative units in Pakistan is almost over, and it is time for decision-makers to act and move forward with the creation of new federating units in the country.
Of late, there have been reports in the Pakistani media that the powers-that-be are almost ready with the draft of the 28th Constitutional Amendment, through which new provinces and administrative units would be created. In this connection, some insightful journalists have revealed that the decision-makers have a plan to hold a referendum to ascertain the opinion of the people of Pakistan on whether they want the formation of new provinces, while also introducing the 28th Constitutional Amendment to complete the process of creating new administrative units.
Simultaneously, certain quarters are also divulging information from the corridors of power that a total of 12 provinces would be formed. Irrespective of the process adopted for the creation of new provinces or administrative units in the country, whether through the 28th Constitutional Amendment, a referendum on the question of creating more provinces, both, or some other mechanism, one thing is quite clear: the creation of new provinces is a sine qua non for Pakistan. A country of nearly 250 million people, with only four provinces and two additional regions that are not fully integrated into the country, namely Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) and Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), cannot be expected to have a sound and stable system of administration and governance.
Although there are several other key reasons for the country’s widespread instability and poor governance, the limited number and enormous size of its federating units make it extremely difficult to administer them effectively. One of the fundamental reasons for the lack of stability and good governance in the country is the absence of sustainable and quality democracy. It may be mentioned here that quality democracy, if not genuine democracy, can emerge from a sustainable electoral and political system. Nevertheless, quality democracy in Pakistan, or in any other country or region, is possible only if a deep-rooted, widespread and flourishing democratic culture exists there.
There is no denying the fact that a strong democratic culture has never taken root at the societal level in Pakistan, as is evident from the deeply entrenched tribal and patriarchal systems in society. Given these dominant social structures, it is difficult to expect a democratic culture to take root and flourish.
Having said that, if there is no strong democratic culture in the country and, consequently, political and economic instability, chaos and poor governance cannot be addressed by strengthening democracy, which seems quite difficult in Pakistan’s prevailing socio-political and economic circumstances, then what is the alternative? This is an interesting question that needs to be addressed.
First, smaller administrative units would make the new provinces administratively and financially viable. At present, every province, including KP, the smallest in terms of area, and Balochistan, the smallest in terms of population, is either too populous or has such vast stretches of land that it is virtually impossible for a chief minister or the provincial cabinet, based in a capital far away from most districts and areas, to manage effectively.
Here, it is important to note that every chief minister in Pakistan has been compelled to include members in the cabinet not on the basis of merit and efficiency but because of political expediency. In other words, a chief minister has to accommodate representatives from almost all geographical subdivisions, as well as major tribes and biradaris (communities) of the province, regardless of whether these cabinet members possess the necessary wisdom and intellectual capacity for their positions. With smaller federating units, chief ministers would be in a much better position to run their administrations on merit, automatically resulting in better governance.
With smaller units, it would be much easier to collect revenues from the local population and, more importantly, spend those funds on providing civic amenities and promoting the development of local communities and areas. Under the existing traditional system of provincial financial administration, direct taxes are collected by the federal authorities through the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), whereas sales, property, octroi and other taxes and fees are collected either directly by provincial governments or local administrations.
The provinces receive funds representing their respective shares from the federal government through the National Finance Commission (NFC) and the Federal Divisible Pool (FDP). The enormous size of the provinces has made it difficult for provincial governments to generate revenues effectively, forcing federal tax authorities to intervene. However, owing to large-scale financial corruption, the appropriate amount of taxes is not collected. With smaller and more manageable provinces, provincial administrations would be better able to identify taxable sectors and areas and implement tax collection strategies efficiently.
Regarding objections raised by different political parties and other quarters to the formation of new provinces, it is important to analyse why they oppose the creation of new federating units. In this regard, the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) and all ethno-nationalist parties in Sindh, such as Jeay Sindh and Awami Tehreek, as well as those in KP, including the Awami National Party (ANP) and Aftab Sherpao’s Qaumi Watan Party (QWP), and parties in Balochistan, such as the Balochistan National Party-Mengal (BNP-M), are important political forces to consider.
The case of the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) is particularly interesting because it has traditionally been vehemently opposed to dividing Punjab, which was once its political stronghold. However, this is no longer necessarily the case.
Since the powers-that-be now appear to favour the creation of more provinces, and the PML-N’s current rule at the federal level and in Punjab is largely due to their support, the party has little choice but to support the formation of new provinces.
The only major political force that has consistently supported the creation of new provinces has been the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI). The PPP and PML-N have opposed the formation of new provinces because both fear that the creation of new federating units would weaken their respective political constituencies in Sindh and Punjab. Their political influence in these provinces is closely linked to winning elections, forming governments and enjoying the associated perks and privileges.
Similarly, ethno-nationalist parties owe their political strength to their provincial rights-based politics, despite having failed to secure the promised rights for their supporters over decades. These parties have repeatedly argued, rather misleadingly, that the existing provinces have existed since time immemorial and are therefore natural and, consequently, sacrosanct. On this basis, they insist that these provinces must never be divided under any circumstances.
In this situation, if the powers-that-be genuinely want to create new provinces, they must move ahead with the plan. This cannot be achieved through the normal political process or by relying solely on existing political forces because most of them, as mentioned above, derive their strength, support base and privileges from the existing provincial structure.
However, Pakistan needs more provinces because the issue is directly linked to the sustainability of the federation, addressing people’s problems and concerns, and putting the country on the path to development. At first glance, it may appear that the majority of people are opposed to the creation of new provinces. However, this is not necessarily the case. It would be reasonable to conclude that most people are neither in favour of nor opposed to the idea. On the one hand, they are largely indifferent to the debate, while on the other, they do not fully understand the potential benefits of creating more provinces.
This situation provides a favourable opportunity to move forward with the creation of additional federating units. Ultimately, the objective should be to establish smaller, more manageable administrative units that can bring governance closer to the people, improve service delivery, strengthen the federation and ensure that the country’s resources are used more effectively for the welfare and development of its population.