FeaturedNationalVOLUME 21 ISSUE # 19

Macroeconomic stability or statistical mirage?

The government has recently sought to reassure the public that Pakistan’s petroleum supplies remain sufficient to meet domestic demand, easing fears of potential shortages amid ongoing geopolitical tensions. Officials have attributed this stability to timely policy decisions, while pointing to improvements in key macroeconomic indicators as evidence of a strengthening external position.
Among these indicators, the current account balance and foreign exchange reserves have shown some positive movement. Pakistan recorded a current account surplus of $427 million in February 2026, a notable increase from the $68 million surplus in January. This improvement was largely driven by a steady rise in workers’ remittances, which reached $3.288 billion in February, compared to $3.127 billion in the same month last year.
However, a closer examination of the broader trend suggests that these gains may not be as robust as they appear. Despite the monthly surplus, the cumulative current account balance for the first seven months of the fiscal year (July–January) remained in deficit at $1.1 billion, according to the Finance Division’s economic update. Including February’s performance, the deficit for the first eight months still stood at $673 million, indicating that structural pressures on the external account persist.
The second indicator cited by the government is the improvement in gross foreign exchange reserves, which reportedly rose to $17.164 billion. While this increase provides some buffer against external shocks, it is important to distinguish between gross and net reserves. Gross reserves reflect the total foreign assets held by the central bank, whereas net reserves account for short-term external liabilities and thus offer a more accurate measure of available liquidity to support the currency.
Data from earlier in February 2026 suggests that reserves were at $16.2 billion, raising questions about the pace and sustainability of their accumulation. Moreover, the relative stability of the exchange rate during this period warrants scrutiny. The rupee remained broadly unchanged — moving marginally from 279.6 per US dollar in February 2025 to around 279.5 by late February 2026 — despite fluctuations in reserve levels. This stability may reflect policy interventions rather than purely market-driven dynamics.
An analysis of the components contributing to the current account surplus further highlights underlying vulnerabilities. The improvement in February appears to have been influenced more by a contraction in imports than by a strengthening of exports.
Exports declined to $2.482 billion in February 2026, down from $2.745 billion in January and also lower than the $2.609 billion recorded in February 2025. At the same time, imports fell to $5.152 billion from $5.346 billion in January. While a reduction in imports can temporarily narrow the trade deficit, it does not necessarily indicate a healthy expansion in economic activity.
In fact, the comparison with February 2025 is instructive. Imports during that period were even lower, at $5.050 billion, but this was largely due to administrative restrictions imposed by the government to curb external imbalances. These measures were later relaxed because they were constraining economic growth, limiting industrial output, and adversely affecting employment and poverty levels.
The recent decline in imports may partly reflect external factors, including disruptions linked to the ongoing Middle East conflict, rather than deliberate policy measures or improvements in domestic productivity. This underscores the fragility of the current account surplus, which may prove difficult to sustain if external conditions change.
More concerning are trends in investment inflows, which paint a less encouraging picture of Pakistan’s economic outlook. Foreign direct investment (FDI) during the July–January period of fiscal year 2025-26 fell sharply to $981.4 million, compared with $1.660 billion in the same period last year — a significant decline of 40.9 percent.
Portfolio investment has also deteriorated, with net outflows reaching negative $463.9 million in the first eight months of the current fiscal year, compared to negative $177 million in the same period last year. This represents a steep increase of 162 percent in outflows, signalling declining investor confidence in Pakistan’s financial markets.
These trends are particularly striking given that Pakistan maintains one of the highest policy interest rates in the region, which would typically be expected to attract foreign capital. The continued outflow of portfolio investment suggests that investors remain concerned about macroeconomic stability, policy consistency, and external risks.
Taken together, these indicators point to a disconnect between headline improvements and underlying economic realities. While the current account surplus and higher reserves offer some short-term relief, they are not sufficient to offset structural weaknesses in trade performance and investment flows.
The government’s emphasis on selective positive indicators risks overlooking deeper challenges that require comprehensive policy responses. A narrow focus on short-term gains may obscure the need for reforms aimed at strengthening export competitiveness, attracting sustainable investment, and improving overall economic resilience.
A more holistic approach to macroeconomic management is therefore essential. Policymakers must assess not only headline figures but also the underlying components driving these outcomes. This includes examining the quality and sustainability of inflows, the composition of trade, and the broader investment climate.
In conclusion, while recent data provides some grounds for cautious optimism, it also highlights the importance of looking beyond surface-level improvements. Pakistan’s economic stability will depend not on isolated indicators, but on a coordinated strategy that addresses structural imbalances, restores investor confidence, and ensures long-term sustainability.

Share: