NationalVOLUME 16 ISSUE # 22

Hollow hopes?

The Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) government has set the national growth rate at about 5pc for the new fiscal year, while it claimed GDP had risen by 3.9pc in the outgoing year. However, international financial organizations dispute the statistics and project the growth rate to be less than half of it.

The World Bank has projected a growth rate of 2pc, while it revised up growth forecast for Pakistan’s economy to 1.3pc for the outgoing fiscal year compared to 0.8pc projected in January, considering an increase in remittance inflows. On the other hand, the Asian Development Bank puts it at 4pc for the next year, though 2pc more than World Bank estimates but still one percent less than what is budgeted.

In its report, the World Bank said Pakistan’s economy has been growing slowly over the past two decades. Annual per capita growth has averaged only 2pc, less than half of the South Asia average, partly due to inconsistent macroeconomic policies and an under-reliance on investment and exports to drive economic growth. Short periods of rapid consumption-fueled growth frequently led to sizable current account and fiscal deficits that ultimately required policy tightening, resulting in recurrent boom-bust cycles. In early FY20, following one such episode of external and fiscal imbalances, the country entered a 39-month IMF-Extended Fund Facility. The associated adjustment measures, including fiscal consolidation, contributed to a reduction of the imbalances over the year and improved macroeconomic stability.

However, the containment measures adopted in response to the COVID-19 pandemic led to a severe contraction in economic activity during the final quarter of FY20. As a result, GDP growth is estimated to have contracted by 1.5 percent in FY20. Half of the working population saw either job or income losses, with informal and low-skilled workers employed in elementary occupations facing the strongest loss in employment. As a result, poverty incidence is estimated to have increased in FY20 from 4.4 to 5.4pc, using the international poverty line of $1.90 PPP 2011 per day, with more than two million people falling below this poverty line. Moreover, 40pc of households suffered from moderate to severe food insecurity. The government, therefore, focused on mitigating the adverse socioeconomic effects of the pandemic through a stimulus package equivalent to approximately 2.9pc of GDP and a deferment of some of the fiscal adjustment measures.

Over the first half of FY21, there have been signs of a fragile recovery. With increased community mobility, private consumption has strengthened, aided by record official remittance inflows. Investment is also estimated to have slightly recovered, as machinery imports and cement sales both recorded double-digit growth rates. On the production side, crop production was relatively weak in the first six months of FY21, as cotton production was adversely affected by heavy monsoon floods. Following the phased lifting of lockdown measures from May 2020 onwards, indicators of industrial and services activity have recovered, with “Large Scale Manufacturing” and business confidence indexes exceeding pre-COVID levels in December 2020. As a result, the majority of the informal workers affected by the crisis are expected to have been able to return to work.

Although headline inflation fell over July-February FY21 (y-o-y), it is still high at 8.3pc on average, mostly on account of high food inflation. Since July 2020, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) has maintained the policy rate at 7pc to support the economy. The capital adequacy ratio at end-December 2020 remained well above the minimum regulatory requirement, indicating banking sector resilience over the first half of the fiscal year. Compared to a deficit of $2 billion for June-December 2019, the current account recorded a surplus of US$1.1 billion for June-December 2020, the first half-yearly surplus in almost a decade, as strong official remittance inflows more than offset a wider trade deficit. Both foreign direct investment and portfolio investment inflows decreased during this period, but the improved current account supported a balance of payments surplus. The Pakistani rupee appreciated by 5.4pc against the U.S. dollar, from end-June 2020 to end-December 2020, and official foreign exchange reserves increased to US$14.9 billion at end-December 2020, equivalent to 3.3 months of imports of goods and services.

The fiscal deficit widened over the first six months of FY21 (y-o-y), as expenditure growth outpaced an increase in revenues. In line with the recovery of economic activity, total revenues grew by 3.7pc. Over the same period, total expenditures rose by 6.2pc, partly driven by higher interest payments. Public debt, including guaranteed debt, reached 87.9pc of GDP at end-December 2020, up from 86.7pc of GDP at end-December 2019. Output growth is expected to recover gradually over the medium-term, averaging 2.2 percent over FY21-23, mostly due to contributions from private consumption. However, sectors that employ the poorest, such as agriculture, are expected to remain weak, and therefore poverty is likely to remain high. The baseline outlook is predicated on the absence of significant infection flare-ups that would require more extensive lockdowns.

The World Bank says major risks to the outlook include the possibility of new waves of infections, the emergence of new vaccine-resistant strains, and setbacks in mass vaccinations. In addition, more delays in the implementation of critical structural reforms could lead to further fiscal and macroeconomic imbalances. According to the IMF, as the recovery gains strength, it will be important to accelerate the implementation of policies and reforms needed to address some of the long-standing challenges facing the Pakistani economy. Moody’s, in its latest report, said that Pakistan’s economy had the potential to grow at an annual rate of 4pc. Fitch Ratings awarded Pakistan ‘B-‘ rating, which reflects weak public finances, external finance vulnerabilities, and low governance indicator scores. “The authorities have made progress in addressing external and public finance challenges over the past few years, despite the headwinds from the Covid-19 pandemic. However, economic uncertainties from the pandemic and political challenges to keeping the reform agenda on track pose risks,” it observed.

It is clear that Pakistan still faces grave challenges and the economy will take years to recover. However, the government wants to create an impression that it has put the country on the road to prosperity. It has taken really harsh measures to improve the economy in three years. Now it has relaxed its policy in a bid to win the next election. All past governments did the same. They relaxed fiscal discipline to woo voters ahead of polls but the country suffered in the end.