How decades of policy failure fueled Pakistan’s energy trap
The energy crisis in Pakistan has been attributed to several issues including lack of adequate energy resources, high fuel prices, and increased demand. Though these issues contribute greatly to the situation, they do not offer an entirely complete picture of the scenario. Rather than a matter of energy shortage, there is a problem of inadequate planning, misuse of the available resources, wrong priorities, and the lack of implementation of measures by the government which could bring down energy costs in the country.
This situation is brought out clearly in yet another recent conference on energy security in Pakistan in which it was noted that the country spends about Rs 3.5 trillion per year in importing energy. A significant part of this money could actually be saved through effective utilization of resources which are available in the country. One of the glaring instances of poor planning is the season-based need for energy. Every year during winters, Pakistan spends $2.7 billion on importing LNG over a span of four months to cater to household needs for heating purposes. At the same time, much of its electricity-generation capacity remains underused. This discrepancy indicates a lack of proper energy planning strategy that considers seasonal consumption trends.
Despite having an electricity-generation capacity of more than 36,000 MW, the base-load requirement of Pakistan for electricity was only 8,000MW from 2015 to 2023. This large gap between generation capacity and actual requirement makes one question the reasoning behind such decisions. Successive governments and authorities did not do proper planning in anticipating change in consumption needs and generating electricity accordingly.
The consequences of this mismanagement are extremely expensive. Pakistan imports costly fuels to meet winter energy needs while continuing to make capacity payments to power producers for generation facilities that are not fully utilised. These payments add to the financial burden on the power sector, contribute to the accumulation of circular debt and ultimately push electricity tariffs higher for consumers.
Another area where government inaction has resulted in substantial economic losses is energy conservation in buildings. Pakistan has yet to make meaningful progress in enforcing building energy-efficiency standards, despite the availability of a federal building code approved in 2023. Research presented at the energy security event suggested that implementing the code could reduce cooling demand by as much as 51pc. However, Punjab, Sindh and Balochistan have still not adopted the code. This delay is difficult to justify when the potential economic benefits are so significant.
As per the study, energy efficiency in only a quarter of housing stock would decrease peak electricity generation by 3,000MW and save Rs442.6 billion annually. The figure can significantly alleviate the stress on the electricity system and keep energy bills low. However, practical steps in this direction have not been taken due to inefficiency in administrative processes and a lack of coordination among federal and provincial governments.
The flaws in Pakistan’s energy system extend beyond generation. Transmission and distribution systems have not been invested in adequately and are associated with heavy losses and mismanagement. The generated electricity is not always transferred to the consumers efficiently due to the constraints of the national grid and DISCOs. This situation creates a vicious cycle, since the inefficiencies in the power sector result in financial loss, and circular debts build up, and the government needs to come out with more financial assistance schemes and tariff revisions again and again. In the end, consumers and industries end up paying more in terms of increased tariffs.
The privatisation of DISCOs is generally seen as one way to improve the efficiency of the power sector. However, it will not be easy to attract genuine investors without solving the problems. Prospective buyers will take into account the case of K-Electric and the problems that they faced due to regulatory issues, payment issues, and government policy issues. It is therefore necessary for the government to provide a clear regulatory structure in order to attract any investors to the power sector.
Payment for capacity of IPPs is yet another issue. According to the current arrangements, IPPs get paid for having their capacity available even if the volume of electricity produced is not as large as initially expected. In order to maintain legality and legitimacy of such an arrangement, the economic cost associated with it needs to become much more transparent.
There needs to be an independent and comprehensive forensic audit of generation capacity, availability of capacity, utilization of capacity, and the terms of agreements. This will determine whether or not the payment is commensurate with the capacity available to the national grid and the terms of agreement. Adherence to contracts should not preclude the need for independent verification of the calculations involved.
Pakistan is equally guilty in failing to make adequate headway in harnessing local energy resources, promoting renewable energy, and increasing domestic production of equipment required for transmission and distribution grids. Such an approach will cut down on imports, create jobs, and improve industry.
A study conducted by Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) has estimated potential local manufacturing possibilities to be worth Rs1.1 trillion. Yet, no tangible efforts have been made towards implementing a previously announced plan for promoting indigenization in the energy sector. This is yet another case of a disparity between policy statements and their implementation.
These deficiencies in Pakistan’s policies have adverse implications in many areas besides the energy sector itself. High cost of electricity translates into high production cost for industries, lowers competitiveness, and makes them less attractive destinations for investments. Pakistani industries are facing fierce competition from other countries in foreign markets. High electricity cost puts them at a disadvantage compared to industries operating in countries with cheaper and reliable electricity.
In cases where industries face high cost of electricity and gas, chances of their expanding their manufacturing base, investing in modern technology or creating new job opportunities become difficult. In other words, the energy crisis becomes a hindrance to the industrialization, export promotion and economic development process.
The most frustrating thing about Pakistan’s energy problems is that all the main problems facing Pakistan have been pinpointed over and again through seminars, conferences and discussions. The loss incurred on account of these deficiencies has already been calculated and remedial measures have already been suggested by researchers. But unfortunately very little implementation has taken place.
What Pakistan lacks is not the research, the suggestions and the policies but the resolve to implement the suggestions. Energy security cannot be gained through costly imports, borrowing more money or increasing tariffs.
Until the state goes beyond mere discussion and begins to act on the necessary measures, the country will go on footing a very heavy bill due to inefficiencies that could have been avoided. This is not the issue anymore. The challenge lies in the implementation of the measures, which require the political and administrative will to do so. It is fair to say that the energy crisis in Pakistan is in many ways a crisis of governance.