FeaturedNationalVOLUME 21 ISSUE # 31

Relief measures offer hope, but reforms remain elusive

The federal budget for fiscal year 2026-27 has been presented at a critical juncture for Pakistan’s economy. After years of economic instability, inflationary pressures, fiscal tightening, and dependence on external financial support, the government has sought to strike a delicate balance between maintaining fiscal discipline and reviving economic growth. While the budget contains several measures aimed at stimulating investment and providing relief to businesses and consumers, it also highlights the persistent structural weaknesses that continue to constrain Pakistan’s economic potential.
With a total outlay of Rs18.77 trillion, the budget is approximately 8.3 percent larger than the revised expenditure estimates for the outgoing fiscal year. The government has projected Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) collections of Rs15.26 trillion, of which nearly Rs8.85 trillion will be transferred to the provinces under the National Finance Commission Award. In addition, non-tax revenues—largely derived from the petroleum levy and profits transferred by the State Bank of Pakistan—are expected to contribute Rs5.34 trillion.
After accounting for provincial transfers, the federal government’s net revenue is projected at Rs11.75 trillion. However, achieving fiscal targets will require substantial cooperation from provincial governments, which have agreed to freeze their share of divisible pool transfers at last year’s level. This arrangement effectively shifts part of the fiscal adjustment burden onto the provinces, requiring them to generate a surplus estimated at Rs1.79 trillion. While this mechanism helps lower the consolidated fiscal deficit from over Rs7 trillion to approximately Rs5.23 trillion, equivalent to 3.6 percent of GDP, it may come at a cost. Provincial governments are likely to reduce spending on development projects and infrastructure programmes, potentially affecting economic activity at the local level. Fiscal consolidation achieved through expenditure compression rather than efficiency improvements may prove difficult to sustain over the long term.
The government has projected economic growth of four percent during the next fiscal year. However, this target appears optimistic given prevailing global and regional uncertainties. The ongoing conflict in the Middle East, disruptions in international supply chains, rising geopolitical tensions, and growing protectionist tendencies among major economies all present significant risks to trade and investment. These external challenges could make achieving the projected growth rate considerably more difficult than official estimates suggest.
One of the most noticeable shortcomings of the budget is the absence of any meaningful effort to broaden the tax base. Despite repeated commitments by successive governments to bring undocumented sectors into the formal economy, progress remains limited. The arrangement reached with traders regarding turnover-based taxation is unlikely to generate substantial revenue or significantly increase tax compliance. A more effective approach would involve enforcing existing laws, including the Shops and Establishment Act, which requires commercial entities to register and maintain proper records. Such a move would help create a comprehensive database of businesses, facilitating documentation and improving tax compliance across the retail and wholesale sectors. Without expanding the tax net, the burden of taxation will continue to fall disproportionately on existing taxpayers and documented businesses.
The budget is guided by three principal objectives: tariff rationalisation, trade facilitation and system efficiency, and targeted economic relief for priority sectors. In pursuit of these goals, the government has proposed reductions in customs duties on industrial inputs across 92 tariff lines. Additional customs duties on nearly 700 tariff categories have been reduced, while regulatory duties on more than 1,700 tariff lines have been scaled back.
These measures are expected to lower production costs, improve industrial competitiveness, and support export-oriented industries. If implemented effectively, they could enhance the business environment and contribute to long-term productivity growth. Several tax reforms introduced in the budget have also been welcomed by investors and businesses. The abolition of the Capital Value Tax on foreign movable and immovable assets removes a levy that many considered an obstacle to capital formation and inconsistent with assurances provided under previous tax amnesty schemes.
Similarly, the government has abolished Section 7E of the Income Tax Ordinance following a court ruling that declared the tax on deemed income from immovable property unconstitutional. While the decision removes a contentious provision from the tax framework, questions remain regarding the treatment of taxes already collected under the now-invalidated law.
The budget also provides relief to businesses through changes in the super tax regime. Companies and individuals with incomes up to Rs500 million have been exempted from the super tax, while rates for higher-income categories have been reduced. Exporters and IT-related businesses have also received tax relief, which could strengthen competitiveness in sectors considered vital for future growth. Another noteworthy measure is the reduction of tax on foreign payments made through cards from five percent to 0.5 percent. The previous rate had encouraged many individuals and businesses to rely on informal channels for international payments, undermining transparency and reducing the effectiveness of official financial systems. The withdrawal of the Federal Excise Duty on business-class airline tickets is another move aimed at reducing distortions within the taxation framework.
Meanwhile, Pakistan continues to benefit from exceptionally strong remittance inflows. Overseas Pakistanis have sent more than $40 billion during the current fiscal year, providing crucial support to foreign exchange reserves and helping the country avoid severe external financing pressures. However, while remittances remain a valuable source of foreign exchange, they cannot substitute for export earnings. Remittances primarily support household consumption and improve liquidity within the economy, but they do not directly create industrial capacity or generate the export growth required for sustainable economic transformation.
Pakistan’s long-term challenge remains the same: breaking free from the recurring cycle of trade deficits and external financing pressures. Achieving this objective requires stronger industrial development, enhanced export competitiveness, and greater productivity across key sectors of the economy. The country also continues to face deeper structural challenges, including rapid population growth, inadequate investment in education and healthcare, rising poverty, and insufficient employment opportunities for a growing workforce. These issues cannot be addressed through short-term fiscal measures alone.
Moreover, heavy government reliance on borrowing continues to create economic vulnerabilities. Increased borrowing fuels inflationary pressures, often prompting the central bank to maintain high interest rates. Higher rates, in turn, increase debt-servicing costs and reduce the fiscal space available for development spending. Ultimately, Pakistan’s economic resilience will depend on the strength of its fundamentals. Industrial capacity, export diversification, logistics infrastructure, fiscal sustainability, and human capital development remain the key pillars upon which long-term prosperity must be built.
The budget contains several positive measures that may provide short-term relief and support economic activity. However, it stops short of addressing many of the structural weaknesses that have constrained growth for decades. Meaningful progress will require comprehensive reforms that extend beyond annual budgetary exercises.
Pakistan’s economic challenges are significant, but they are not insurmountable. A coherent long-term strategy supported by political consensus, institutional continuity, and effective implementation can gradually place the economy on a more sustainable path. The first step is recognising that durable economic transformation requires more than temporary incentives or fiscal adjustments; it demands a sustained commitment to reform, productivity, and competitiveness.
Only through such an approach can Pakistan move beyond recurring crises and achieve the stable, inclusive, and sustainable growth that its citizens have long sought.

Share: